data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/56e2c/56e2cefd3a505a64e709c6b9c0397c236ad22cc2" alt=""
I think it's intriguing when researchers are able to x-ray paintings and see what decisions artists made about what to add or eliminate. In A Woman Asleep (also called A Girl Asleep), although it's very hard to see, there once was a dog in the doorway on the right and a man in the back room. Vermeer decided to paint both of them out. Of course we'll never know why, but it seems that in many of his painting
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4013f/4013f34edc8808df599c3052eba8bbd962e8bec4" alt=""
I don't know, but it seems to me that A Woman Asleep is a tad more interesting without all the detail. We can see there is some sort of overturned goblet and that the table covering is bunched up. A big gathering to clean up after? Legitimately tired after hard work? Or shirking her duties after a few drinks? Critics have naturally noticed and commented on the cupids on the wall behind her. We don't know more and never will and that's what I like about it. What do you think?
P.S. Since another Vermeer, The Milkmaid, below, came to the Met in NY last fall, there's been a lot written about whether or not there is a good deal or just a little suggestiveness intended by Vermeer in his depiction of her. Click on the Met's link in this paragraph to read more.
I agree with you about the details in the foreground (lovely as they are to behold). It's probably a commentary on sloth, or some related sin. Could this be the Rembrandt that inspired it?
ReplyDeleteThe x-ray looks a bit like a Rauschenberg!
Actually I think I just found the Rembrandt - couldn't get the link to transfer to this comment area so I'll just add it to the blog above. The pose is almost identical to Vermeer's. And you're right, the x-ray does look kind of like a Rauschenberg. . .
ReplyDeleteYes, it's terribly suggestive. I expect it to show up in a Victoria's Secret catalog any day now.
ReplyDeleteSeriously, not suggestive to me but absolutely lovely.